Math vs Maths - grammer fight
Can we please all get something straight, the word origin is MathematicS thus the abbreviation HAS to be Maths.
Of all the american bastardisations of English, this must be the one that gets furthest up my nose.
If you don't stop misusing the language I will have to adopt the persona of an enraged high school student and gun you feckers down!
Of all the american bastardisations of English, this must be the one that gets furthest up my nose.
If you don't stop misusing the language I will have to adopt the persona of an enraged high school student and gun you feckers down!
- kitty on catnip
- Lux Elder
- Posts: 2209
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2006 12:34 pm
- Location: BACK IN THE FORUMS...
- Contact:
but smedz, noone in the U.S uses 'maths' , they just say math. It is just a natural development of the language across billions of people and many years. It isn't really wrong, it's just different than you. I mean, if a child goes to 'math' class every day of their lives, you can't really blame them for using the term 'math', cause that is what they are taught.
...just as the UK - is the collective formation of nations (including but probably not limited to) England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland -smedz wrote:Mathematics is a collective term for the studies (note plural) of Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry and Calculus.
No need to force your 'Common-wealthic Views' on the rest of us Smedz -
What is Arithmetic - I noticed you left it out of Math(s) - is that sort of why Greenland is not included as part of North America (Preach) - or does it have something more to do as to why Europe is not a part of Asia?
- Black Pope
- Lux Exorcist
- Posts: 3878
- Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 5:36 pm
- Location: God's Right Hand
- Preacherman
- Semiholy Priest
- Posts: 4496
- Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 3:52 am
- Location: Sweden (capital of Denmark, an island in Norway, southern Europe)
- Contact:
- kitty on catnip
- Lux Elder
- Posts: 2209
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2006 12:34 pm
- Location: BACK IN THE FORUMS...
- Contact:
- Drifter
- Semiholy Rambler
- Posts: 6770
- Joined: Sun Nov 20, 2005 5:06 pm
- Location: An undisclosed location... for reasons of security, and therefore... insecurity...
- Contact:
It seems that during the boat ride from Great Britian to North America the "s" was lost in shipping. Ask Oxford.
So we can chalk this up to yet another mistake ... The bastion of the English Language says "Maths" yet because you inbred hicks couldn't be bothered pronouncing the "s" we all have to accept that "Math" has evolved into something acceptable.Drifter wrote:It seems that during the boat ride from Great Britian to North America the "s" was lost in shipping. Ask Oxford.
Shall we chalk it up with Tire (Tyre), Curb (Kerb) and Aluminum (Aluminium) - lets not even get onto all those missing u's.
As for 3 card cash, You are most likely to get them when least needed!
of course, it is also entirely possible that the US took the word from another language such as German (Math = Mathematik) or that the abbreviation 'math' spread from somewhere like Minnesota with a lot of German immigrants ...Drifter wrote:It seems that during the boat ride from Great Britian to North America the "s" was lost in shipping. Ask Oxford.
... just thinking aloud ...
and trying to annoy a fellow Brit
Hoodie -
It may well be usually treated as singular but it is grammatically incorrect.
For instance - if we were to take a noun such as "elephant" and shorten it to "phant" for the sake of simplicity then surely if you were to refer more than one "phant" you would add an 's'. Abbreviation does not change the rules of pluralisation.
We all agree that math is short for mathmatics and
we all agree that there are many types of mathmatics. Math requires an 's' to indicate its plural form otherwise it is written as " a math" when using it as a singular noun.
It may well be usually treated as singular but it is grammatically incorrect.
For instance - if we were to take a noun such as "elephant" and shorten it to "phant" for the sake of simplicity then surely if you were to refer more than one "phant" you would add an 's'. Abbreviation does not change the rules of pluralisation.
We all agree that math is short for mathmatics and
we all agree that there are many types of mathmatics. Math requires an 's' to indicate its plural form otherwise it is written as " a math" when using it as a singular noun.
- my wife hates me
- Lux Elder
- Posts: 2664
- Joined: Fri Sep 22, 2006 4:45 am
- Location: I TOOK MY BED BACK
- Contact:
as a (part-time) language teacher I have to say this is not necessarily the case.Sidhe wrote:We all agree that math is short for mathmatics and
we all agree that there are many types of mathmatics. Math requires an 's' to indicate its plural form otherwise it is written as " a math" when using it as a singular noun.
There are many 'uncountable' nouns - such as 'rice' 'money', 'information' etc - which are the same in the singular and plural form.
'I had rice for breakfast' obviously means I ate more than one grain of rice.
Mathematics is clearly an uncountable noun - we say 'mathematics was my worst subject' not were.
There are other similar nouns out there - logistics, linguistics - and the question is whether the abbreviated form of these should be 'log' or 'logs'.
The logical abbreviation of the word 'mathematics' would have to be 'math' because to keep the 's' would be to suggest it is a countable noun.
In short, the word 'mathematics' ends in 's' but it is an uncountable noun so the 's' has no grammatical significance and therefore is not necessary in the abbreviated form.
nietzsche hurries off his application for a green card
- kitty on catnip
- Lux Elder
- Posts: 2209
- Joined: Tue Jun 06, 2006 12:34 pm
- Location: BACK IN THE FORUMS...
- Contact:
- One Big Wave
- Lux Emo Star
- Posts: 1680
- Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 11:20 pm
- Location: Hiding
- AquaRegia
- Lux Ambassador
- Posts: 3721
- Joined: Sat Jan 01, 2005 6:20 am
- Location: Lounging once more at the mods' retirement villa
- Contact:
So I have a question for smedz which will settle it for me - answer honestly:
Do you say a) "Maths IS my favourite subject" or b) "Maths ARE my favourite subjects"?
If the answer is b), then I will happily agree with you. If a), however, then your argument falls to pieces, a victim of the perpetual illogic of the English language we both so love. You are using "maths" as a singular noun, as shown by both the verb (is) and the object (subject). It doesn't make sense to have it both ways; but of course, LOTS of things about English don't make sense.
Is that good enough?
Do you say a) "Maths IS my favourite subject" or b) "Maths ARE my favourite subjects"?
If the answer is b), then I will happily agree with you. If a), however, then your argument falls to pieces, a victim of the perpetual illogic of the English language we both so love. You are using "maths" as a singular noun, as shown by both the verb (is) and the object (subject). It doesn't make sense to have it both ways; but of course, LOTS of things about English don't make sense.
The only way you have the hated "4 no cash" is to have 2 pair. In the hypothetical "simplest case" (i.e., holding 3 cards and picking a 4th one from an otherwise complete deck), the odds are 13/42 of picking one of the cards that gives you the dreaded 2 pair, which is just about 30%. Of course, this doesn't factor in the odds of NOT having a cash on 3.Golgi wrote:What I really want to know is:
What are the chances of NOT being able to cash with 4 cards?
Is that good enough?
Taking on the Oxford English Dictionary is one thing, challenging Julia is quite the opposite ... I urge you to consider your position for the good of all men!nietzsche wrote:as a (part-time) language teacher I have to say this is not necessarily the case.Sidhe wrote:We all agree that math is short for mathmatics and
we all agree that there are many types of mathmatics. Math requires an 's' to indicate its plural form otherwise it is written as " a math" when using it as a singular noun.
There are many 'uncountable' nouns - such as 'rice' 'money', 'information' etc - which are the same in the singular and plural form.
'I had rice for breakfast' obviously means I ate more than one grain of rice.
Mathematics is clearly an uncountable noun - we say 'mathematics was my worst subject' not were.
There are other similar nouns out there - logistics, linguistics - and the question is whether the abbreviated form of these should be 'log' or 'logs'.
The logical abbreviation of the word 'mathematics' would have to be 'math' because to keep the 's' would be to suggest it is a countable noun.
In short, the word 'mathematics' ends in 's' but it is an uncountable noun so the 's' has no grammatical significance and therefore is not necessary in the abbreviated form.
nietzsche hurries off his application for a green card
Now as for kitty, I find it intersting that (a) you could assume I wasn't joking and (b) that your choice of phrase suggests that you already consider me to be ignorant and that making such a statement would simply prove that to be the case.
By placing "is" in the sentence, you suggest that my "ignorance" is a given and that the statement simply proves the point, clearly this shows to me that you cannot correctly structure a sentence and thus have an "ignorance" all of your own.Kitty on Catnip wrote:That would definitely show how ignorant he is
I would never "Maths is my favourite subject" as I happen to hate it, however I would never say "Math is my favourite subject" .... because the word is Maths.AquaRegia wrote: Something clever
Havatcha!
- my wife hates me
- Lux Elder
- Posts: 2664
- Joined: Fri Sep 22, 2006 4:45 am
- Location: I TOOK MY BED BACK
- Contact:
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 57 guests